I was just reading Martin Luther's writings on Law and Gospel and I began to think, does the ELCA only proclaim the Gospel and the LCMS and WELS only proclaim the Law? Which is worse?
(for you readers who aren't Lutheran nerds, ELCA= evangelical lutheran church in america and the other two are the missouri and wisconsin synod churches which are much smaller and more conservative lutheran denominations)
The ELCA probably errs on the side of Gospel, but that's certainly not all you hear. I can't really speak about LCMS or WELS. I've never worshipped in their congregations and don't pay much attention to their official pronouncements. Which is worse? I don't know. You can't recognize the Gospel if you haven't been convicted by the law. However, unrelenting law just drives you down. The trick has always been the careful balance of both.
Posted by: CoG | September 19, 2006 at 07:43 PM
I grew up in an LCMS congregation and attended LCMS schools from K-12. While I am no longer a member of a Lutheran congregation, I am grateful for the spiritual training I received.
What I value most from my childhood training in spiritual matters is a deep conviction of grace. Through elementary school where we memorized the catechism, Bible verses and hymns. I learned that the most important thing I could know about God was that He loved me. The confirmation process and high school faith-related classes deepened that understanding of grace.
As a matter of fact, my early youthful "rebellious" spritual searching sent me searching in more fundamentalist direction.
It was the constant emphasis on grace that kept me from staying there, and has continued to be a theme and the most important facet of how I view God.
So, at least in my experience, I haven't seen any emphasis on law over grace in LCMS.
Posted by: Mia | September 20, 2006 at 11:29 PM
ELCA thinking is usually that it is better to err on the side of grace than law and I am guilty but I've met some LCMS pastors that are graceful.
Posted by: rich | October 04, 2006 at 02:04 PM